Buyer's Premiums At An Auction In Mesa

Buyer's premiums are increasing in popularity and yet

, have created significant industry controversy. Some of this controversy has now spilled over into the auction press. In an issue of the Auctioneer (the official monthly publication of the National Auctioneers Association), John H. Miles discusses the positive aspects of charging buyer's premiums in an article entitled "Buyer's Premium: To Charge or Not To Charge?". However, Mr. Miles praise of buyer's premiums is rather faint and his rationalizations for using buyer's premiums somewhat disquieting.

Mr. Miles' compares the use of buyer's premiums to the illegal marketing tactic of using false markups and markdowns to create the impression of a sale price. He chooses words that carry an implied perception of deceitful behavior ("...buyer's sometimes fall for that type of gimmick.") Do we really want to promote an industry practice that requires customers to fall for a "gimmick"? Mr. Miles also admits that the introduction of buyer's premiums into relationships between conductors of an auction in Mesa and sellers can be deceptive ("Sellers will be approached with all types of buyer's premium liquidation proposals that may sound good on the surface...").

Mr. Miles' article attempts to analyze the impact of buyer's premiums on total auction in Mesa revenue but does not do so in a balanced way. He focuses solely on the impacts of charging buyer's premiums of 10% or under while buyer's premiums of greater than 10% are dismissed as "typically not recommended". Buyer's premiums of over 10% actually decrease auction in Mesa revenue and result in 100%, or even 100+%, of the buyer's premium coming out of the seller's final proceeds. The conductor of an auction in Mesa who charges 3% straight commission and 15% buyer's premium may actually be charging the seller the equivalent of 20% straight commission!!

As a counter point to John Miles' previous article in favor of buyer's premiums, I would like to discuss one major negative of buyer's premiums.

Buyer's Premiums Create Intense Buyer Dissatisfaction

I have never heard a single buyer say anything positive about buyer's premiums. Bidders may become resigned, or even accustomed to paying a buyer's premium, but they don't like the premium. Buyer's feelings about buyer's premiums range from simple annoyance at having to constantly subtract the premium from their bid amounts; to rage at having been tricked into paying too much by the use of a "gimmick". In Arizona (my home state), where many auctions in Mesa do not charge buyer's premiums, bidders will often choose between two auctions in Mesa on the basis of which auction in Mesa does not charge a buyer's premium.

If a consultant came to you with a proposal to increase your business revenue by charging your customers an additional 10% that would net you 3% in increased revenue but at the cost of dramatically increased customer dissatisfaction, would you even seriously consider the proposal? High levels of customer dissatisfaction seem a terrible price to pay for an additional 3% profit. Many conductors of auctions in Mesa who are adamantly opposed to conductors of auctions in Mesa bidding at their own auctions in Mesa, because of the customer dissatisfaction it creates, don't give a second thought to charging buyer's premiums, which create at least an equal amount of customer dissatisfaction.

by: Deb Weidenhamer

POST COMMENT

Mesa Auctioneers: Buyer Premiums 3G auction process Basic premise of penny bid auctions Successful eBay Sellers Do These 10 Things...You Should Too! How To Identify Hot Selling Niches On eBay Quickly, Easily And For Free What To Find Out About An Reo Auction How to ensure that you are not betrayed as well as winning points on Pay per bid auctions USA 10 Most Expensive Vintage Toys Sold On Ebay Jade Jewelry And Other Treasures Will Be Auctioned 300 (map) - Jade, Diamonds, Precious Stones - Penny Auction Strategy What to Do Before Bidding on a Property at Auctions BidSaucer Penny Auctions Advantages Galore In Penny Auctions