How Will BP Survive the Oil Spill?
How Will BP Survive the Oil Spill?
How Will BP Survive the Oil Spill?
The Gulf of Mexico BP oil spill has put British oil giant British Petroleum (BP - Analyst Report) squarely at the top of the corporate exile list. This environmental disaster BP oil spill has not only made BP everybody's chief villain, but also put an unappealing public spotlight on the oil industry's Achilles heel: deepwater drilling.
While the BP oil spill impairment to the environment and Gulf Coast businesses is very genuine, this BP oil spill crisis and its effects are also expected to create its own set of winners and losers. On top of the losers list is BP, which has not only lost more than a third of its market value, but is also facing doubts about BP's ability to exist as an independent entity.
Real and speculative stories about BP going the rounds in recent days range from the risk of government expropriation of the company to its materialization as a buyout target to talk of a dividend cut. The goal in this write-up is to size up these stories to answer the greatest question of whether BP can go on in its present shape.
Government Expropriation on BP
Let's take on the simplest issue (mainly a rumor) first -- that the U.S. government will seize all or part of BP's assets. This is a non-existent threat and doesn't hold any water. The U.S. is a country of laws, with a proud tradition of property rights. While BP is no doubt exposed to a host of liabilities and lawsuits, including the Justice Department's civil and/or criminal probes, they will be all be determined under the due process of law. BP may be a pariah, but there should be no disbelief that it will get non-discriminatory and transparent judicial treatment.
Is BP a Buyout Target?
After losing about a third of its market value, BP's market capitalization has slipped from being the second among the five super majors -- Exxon (XOM - Analyst Report), BP, Chevron (CVX - Analyst Report), Shell (RDS.A - Analyst Report) and Total (TOT - Analyst Report) -- to around the same level as France's Total. BP's diminished value has prompted rumors that it could be in play, with Exxon and Shell often cited as the potential acquirers.
While BP's lucrative portfolio of oil and natural gas assets would make it an attractive target, it is not considered a viable option for three reasons. First, no super-major would like to shoulder the unquantifiable liability exposure of BP. Second, anti-trust concerns in the U.S. and Europe would make such a pattern a hard sell. And third, BP has a considerable downstream (refining & marketing) presence, which isn't of interest to any of the super-majors.
How Secure is the BP Dividend?
This may essentially be the more plausible of all the concerns about BP, given the company's deep set of current problems. However, there are two aspects to the BP dividend decision -- financial and perceptional (or political).
Let's deal with the financial aspect first. Looking thoroughly at the BP's financial profile, I wouldn't think the dividend to be at risk. Behind this view is a conservative look at the BP's cash flows this year and next versus its need for capital expenditures, dividend payouts and other oil spill related liabilities.
BP plans to pay out around $22 billion on capital expenditures this year and around that similar level next year, while its annual dividend payouts amount to around $10.5 billion. In terms of operating cash flows, BP will generate anywhere from $25 billion to $34 billion this year, depending on oil prices ranging from $60 per barrel to $80 per barrel (keeping natural gas constant at $5 per Mcf). As long as oil and natural gas prices remain in this range or above, BP will have sufficient internal cash flows to meet these needs.
In addition to its ample operating cash flow cover, BP also has a reasonably strong balance sheet, notwithstanding its recent rating downgrades that still leave it in pristine investment-grade territory. BP had a net debt-to-capitalization ratio of around 19% as of the end of the first quarter. This leaves BP sufficient capacity to improve debt to meet its obligations. BP also has an ongoing asset disposition program that can be expanded to raise more cash.
The point is that from a purely financial standpoint, BP has sufficient resources to meet its needs without needing to cut the dividend.
The Politics of the Dividend
But continuing to pay the dividend may not be a purely financial decision from the BP management's perspective. This message came across clearly in the conference call that BP management held for investors on Friday. BP management highlighted on the call the importance of the dividend to shareholders, but failed to give categorical assurance of its safety.
Political rhetoric on the dividend issue has been heating up in recent days. A number of senators have stated that they would like BP to suspend its dividend while the full picture of its spill-related cost liability remains unclear. And even the President commented on it last week stating that 'I don't want to hear BP is nickel and diming' the Gulf Coast residents while it continues to spend money on image advertising and dividends.
The bottom-line is that while financially BP may be able to support its dividend, the political backdrop may make it untenable.
Sizing Up the Liability Related to the BP Oil Spill
All of this analysis comes down to the eventual size of the BP's total liability exposure resulting from the BP oil spill. And that is not easy to quantify -- at least not at this stage.
A point of reference could be the 1989 Exxon Valdez oil spill, which eventually cost ExxonMobil $4.5 billion, including clean-up costs, legal settlements and punitive damages. But BP is sitting on a much bigger oil spill disaster, and as a result will be footing a much bigger bill than BP.
BP has already spent around $1.3 billion in cumulative BP oil spill related costs, which works out to a roughly $28 million daily cost since the explosion about 45 days ago. For making a 'guesstimate,' I rely on the assumption that this estimated daily spend run rate continues, at least through the end of the completion of the relief well into late August. That works out to additional gross outlays of about $2.4 billion, bringing the total at that stage to about $3.7 billion.
But BP oil spill clean up will most likely continue for awhile beyond that stage. An admittedly arbitrary doubling of the guesstimate -- to account for oil spill clean-up costs beyond August -- would take the gross tally to $7.4 billion. As noted earlier, this is a very rough estimate, and the actual number will almost certainly be completely different.
Then there is the very valid issue of litigation, both from Gulf Coast residents and businesses and as well as the Federal and State governments. While some estimation could be made of expected penalties under the Clean Water Act, for example, it is extremely difficult to have a full appreciation of the the BP liability exposure from future litigation.
But while the extent of that exposure is indefinite at this stage, it is adequate to assume that it will be years before BP has to make payments. For reference, keep in mind that Exxon finished its final liability payment related to the 1989 spill only a short time ago.
We should keep in mind that BP owns 65% of the oil well in question, with the rest of the 35% held by Anadarko (APC - Analyst Report) and Japan's Mitsui. While BP apparently will have the main share of the liability exposure, it will not be 100% of the total, either.
Can BP Survive the Oil Spill?
There is no doubt that the BP appearance and reputation has been tattered by this BP oil spill. And the financial liabilities for this BP oil spill will no doubt be large. But we doubt that even a massive liability bill -- of, say, $25 billion to $30 billion -- spread over multiple years can cripple this very resource-rich company. BP carries an investment-grade credit profile, owns billions of barrels in precious oil reserves, and generates a lot of money.
So, while the BP stock may be risky and inappropriate for a lot of investors, the BP existence is not in doubt, in my view.
How Does a Tension Leg Platform (TLP) Work? Selecting the Greatest Office Filling Cabinet System Your UK Pre-nuptial Agreement - Look After The Detail Roulette Advisor-Roulette Advisor Ayn Rand Quotations How a Deluge System Works Birth Records Illinois Endless colours with abstract thinking Getting Iron Stains off from the Toilet Forel Publishing Company-Forel Publishing About Oolongs The Evolution Trap: Balancing Belief In The Biblical God With Intellectual Credibility Do you want to be a Hero?