subject: 16 Rooms Were Demolished Farmers Without Land Certificate Is Revoked A Penny Of Compensation [print this page] Ma Chengwen Tongxin County of Wuzhong City in Ningxia, a farmer. 3 years ago, his 16 houses and 17 acres of arable land, is the county government demolitions, occupancy, and he refused to accept an administrative reconsideration to the city.
Wuzhong concentric municipal government recognized the illegal practice of the county government, and in August last year, ordered to return the Ma Chengwen Tongxin County land use rights. But until today, the county government not only failed to perform concentric higher levels of government in the administrative ruling, but lifted Ma Chengwen of land use right certificate.
So why the courage to rebel against higher concentric county government decree? Wuzhong behavior for such a confrontation, what way? Effectiveness of the administrative review decision should be how to maintain? How can the interests of ordinary Hp f4809a battery be protected?
16 rooms are demolished without a penny of compensation
60-year-old farmer Ma Chengwen concentric County, now living in a bungalow in the inside. Ma Chengwen house originally had a 2,000 square meters large yard, the street has 16 houses, real estate certificates, land certificates, land management warrants, "three cards" complete. A 12 people rely on external rental housing and farming life, about 3 million a year income, poverty-stricken counties in concentric conditions be such a good nor bad.
In 2007, the concentric County North ditch treatment project implementation, Ma Chengwen a street of houses were identified as illegal buildings, 16 houses were forcibly removed.
"Said I was zoning and building regulations, when my building is not illegal, is not illegal to live for 20 years, to the illegal demolition of the time that I had. Concentric issued by the county government does not recognize anything in 20 years, there is the truth?" Ma Chengwen still are indignant.
Ma Chengwen far as the hospital was removed to obtain the compensation for house, street demolished 16 houses and 17 acres of land occupied did not get a penny.
Apply for administrative reconsideration to win
Ma Chengwen demolitions of the county government decided against Concentric in 2008, the county government to the higher authorities Wuzhong concentric municipal government for administrative reconsideration request confirmation concentric county government illegal.
Reconsideration period, Wuzhong concentric municipal leaders to coordinate and solve the county, but the county government not only failed to deal with concentric, also Ma Chengwen homestead built a house on the start.
Mediation several times to no avail, August 2009, Wuzhong city to make the final decision of reconsideration, finds that the illegal acts of concentric county government should be the return of Ma Chengwen of land use rights.
County government refused to honor the city decided to
Got the administrative reconsideration decision, has been renting the Ma Chengwen a thought back to the original home soon, and did not expect "administrative reconsideration decision" after the service, the county government did not implement Wuzhong concentric municipal government's decision. October 2009, Wuzhong City conducted a performance to do supervision on the matter, but until today, the administrative reconsideration decision issued a year later, still no return of Ma Chengwen Tongxin County land.
So why the concerted refusal to perform on the county level of government - the executive resolution Wuzhong it?
SU Xiao concentric County Deputy County Manager explained that because Ma Chengwen legitimacy obtained land certificates, with a resolution of Wuzhong City where there is disagreement, the county land certificate for the return of Ma Chengwen reservations, so there is no implementation Wuzhong City decision.
"In the wrong place to send the card issuing" certificates of land acquisition procedures Ma Chengwen have any questions? County Legislative Affairs Director Luo Zhongkai made further explained that because of county government staff, control is lax, irresponsible and illegal to Macheng Wen made the "three cards."
County Counsel Guyi Jiang also pointed out that Wuzhong city hp pavilion dv4 battery, "the administrative reconsideration decision" error of fact, the applicable law is wrong.
Revocation of concentric County farmers "three cards"
Therefore, the county has not implemented Wuzhong concentric municipal resolution. But Luo Zhongkai Director said that the decision of the municipal government even though that has all sorts of Wuzhong inappropriate, but the views of the city, or to be executed, concentric county government is not "letter" of the execution, but to take a flexible approach that is, in consultation with the Ma Chengwen.
Macheng Wen said that because of unsuccessful negotiation, the county government compensated him a 54 square meters, there is no ownership of the house, unable to protect his family's future life 12.
Although Luo Zhongkai and Guyi Jiang stressed that the county government is not against Wu Zhong concentric municipal government's decision, but try and Ma Chengwen negotiated settlement, but reporters found that concentric County Wuzhong supervision process, yet Ma Chengwen "three card" revoked , and to make administrative decisions with Wuzhong city opposite behavior.
Attorney in Macheng Wen Xu Zidong view, this behavior is essentially against the Wuzhong City decision. "Concentric County's property titles to Ma Chengwen revocation to the actual behavior of a view that, in fact, against the higher authorities of the correct legal decision, in essence, violates the legitimate rights and interests of the Macheng Wen."
Well, initiated by the concentric County "negotiated settlement" to reach agreement on when? If the parties fail to reach consensus, then how? For this problem, Luo Zhongkai and Guyi Jiang did not directly answer.
Wuzhong: only urge
Administrative reconsideration decision not to implement a year-long, Wuzhong City decision making body is how to treat it? How to ensure their effectiveness of administrative hp pavilion dv5 battery made by it?
Wuzhong Juan Ma, deputy director of Office of Legislative Affairs, said that the complexities of administrative reconsideration cases, is their unexpected, which is more than they run in the first case.
Difficult issues facing immediate, MA Juan, said the municipal government has not Wuzhong effective way to resolve too. Juan Ma said that as Wuzhong no legal enforcement powers granted only to supervise.
However, to what time supervision, Ma Juan said that the law does not require such a schedule, that is concentric to delay for 10 years and run village, in the law can not be said to be illegal.
Juan Ma, then intriguing.
"Supervision to when? Nodes have no time?"
"Law does not provide."
"The law does not require the implementation of lower levels of government decision to lower levels of government have no time limit on it?"
"No."
"If he dragged a decade or how to do it?"
"No way, this is the law of the blank."
Institute of Sociology, Sichuan Academy of Social Sciences has been concerned about Hu Guangwei, deputy director of such problems, he said, "concentric event" in the country is not a solitary case, the higher the executive decision to defy the effects brought about is very serious.
"People of faith there is no executive branch of government, and government agencies the authority did not. Social management is a mess, this is a county, each county is so against the higher administrative authority, there is no way to manage, the higher the authority of the full hp pavilion dv7 battery. "Hu Guangwei worried that such incidents give the" butterfly effect. "
How embarrassing encounter Wuzhong city break? Who will protect the rights of farmers Ma Chengwen? Voice of China will continue to focus.
