Does A Once-a-day Vitamin Improve Depression?

Wouldn't it be terrific if a one-a-day multi-vitamin fought depression

? They are available in any grocery store. They are low-cost. They are easy to take. But do they alleviate depression? Researchers have examined this question.

Researchers gathered volunteers for a depression study and randomly placed them into four groups: (1) a multi-vitamin group (2) a B-vitamin group and (3) a placebo group and (4) a group that received nothing. The multi-vitamin group took multi-vitamins and the B vitamin participants took B vitamins. The placebo group took a tablet that looked like the others but contained a ingredient that should have no impact (basically a "sugar pill"). What the scientists found was interesting: Anyone taking a tablet had a slight improvement in their depression -- it did not matter if the tablet was a B vitamin, a multi-vitamin, or the "sugar pill" equivalent. The scientists credit the change to a "placebo effect" -- the act of taking a pill had an impact. B vitamins and multi-vitamins had the same impact as a non-vitamin. Participants improved because they believed the supplement would help their depression and so it did. This study suggests vitamins do not matter, but is that true?

The research examined B vitamins along with multi-vitamins. Take a look at the B vitamin example in more detail. The issue missing in this research is that not all of us have the need for more B vitamins. If low levels of B vitamins are implicated in our depression, taking B vitamins may improve our case. If we have enough B vitamins already, why would more vitamins matter? Absent in the study is a determination of the patients' need for B vitamins. There are studies, particularly of the elderly, that show a strong link between vitamin B-12 and depression. Elderly people as a group tend to be deficient in vitamin B-12 In fact, researchers are recommending that people take a B-12 and B-6 vitamin to prevent the deficiency and, thereby, protect against the depression. There is some indication that B vitamins fight depression if the victim is deficient in those vitamins.

What about that once-a-day vitamin? Multi-vitamin are designed to help you avoid deficiencies over the long term. If you have a high need for a specific vitamin, the once-a-day vitamin dosage will probably not meet your need. In that case, you are not meeting your need with a daily vitamin. As with the B vitamin illustration, you cannot correct a B-12 deficiency with a multi-vitamin (not very quickly in any case). For all other vitamins, the story is the same. You need to identify what your body needs and then find a way to meet the need.

A daily vitamin is a short-range shot gun. You need a sniper rifle.

Vitamins can improve depression if if they are meeting a need that your body has. Your job is to figure out what those vitamins are and begin a regimen to improve them. Ask your doctor to give you a plasma homocysteine test for your B vitamin levels. Check your vitamin D, iron, and zinc levels. Start taking fish oil. You may find a solution sooner than you think.

by: Alexander V. Martin

POST COMMENT

How antidepressants help in fighting against depression? The Amazing Effects Of Aromatherapy Remedies In Reducing Depression Beating Depression SAD Desk Lamp reviews and ratings - What sad Lamp is best to overcome Depression? How to relief Depression problem naturally How To Relieve Depression From The Inside Out How To Beat Depression Before It Beats You Learn More About Types Of Depression Menopause And Depression Facts Revealed Depression Causes - Learning To See The Painful Truth Sudden Depression What Is Depression? Getting Past Those Nasty Depression Blues