What Is A Unit Of Translation?
Being one of the fundamental concepts always argued about in the realm of translation
, the unit of translation (UT) has been given various definitions by different theorists. Shuttleworth and Cowie define it as: "a term used to refer to the linguistic level at which ST is recodified in TL". In other words, it's an element with which the translator decides to work while translating the ST.
When a translator commences his work, i.e. translation, in accordance with the type of ST he's working on, he decides about the basic segments in ST to be translated into TT. These segments range from a whole text, as in poetry, to a single phoneme.
The argument about the length of a UT also dates back to the conflict between free vs. literal translation. Literal translation is much focused on individual words, or even sometimes morphemes. Therefore in literal translation UTs are as short as words. On the contrary, a free translation "aims at capturing the sense of a longer stretch of
language". It always chooses the sentence. Of course by the arising of text linguistics, the concentration of free translation has moved from the sentence to the whole text. Once a translator decides to work on larger segments than is necessary to convey the meaning of ST, this is free translation which is at work.
Several types of UT are recognized as: 1- functional units, 2-semantic units, 3- dialectic units and 4- prosodic units. The last three types are, according to them, counted as UT but the functional units are almost too long to include just one UT. Three other different categories arise while looking at the relationship between units of translation and words inside a text:
1 - Simple units: Vinay and Darbelnet correspond this type to a single word. It's the simplest, as they state, and at the same time the most widely used unit. In this case, number of units equals number of words. Replacement of words will not lead to a change in the sentence structure.
2 - Diluted units: These units contain several words which in turn shape a lexical unit, since they pursue a single idea.
3 - Fractional units: "A fraction of a word" is what this type of UTs are consisted of.
For Newmark, "sentence is a natural unit of
translation". He then considers some other sub-units of translation in the sentence, the first of which is the morpheme. Unless placed in special cases, Newmark states, morphemes shouldn't be considered seriously. Clause, group, collocation and words including idioms and compounds are grammatical and lexical sub-units of translation proposed by him. For sure Newmark's proposed category partly relies on a scale formerly established by Michael Halliday in 1985.
Newmark considers no priority for each of the lexical or grammatical units, since wherever they exist, he believes, enough importance should be paid toward them.
Briefly speaking, Newmark labels paragraphs and texts as higher UTs, while sentences, groups, clauses and words as lower UTs. He contends that "the mass of translation uses a text as a unit only when there are apparently insuperable problems at the level of the collocations, clause or sentence level". Recent emphasis on communicative competence and language is what Newmark counts as a factor which had made the text as unit renowned. In his terms, most of the translation is done at the smaller units, i.e. word and clause.
Trying to delve more into the details and providing a clearer elaboration on the concept of UT, Newmark states that in informative and authoritative texts, the focus is on the word, in informative texts on the collocation and the group and in vocative texts on the sentence and the text, as a unit.
He concludes in this way: "all lengths of language can, at different moments and also simultaneously, be used as units of translation in the course of the translation activity to me the unit of translation is a sliding scale, responding according to other varying factors, and ultimately a little unsatisfactory".
Aunes Oversettelser AS has been in the business for 26 years, and we are specialized in technical translations. We are specializing in the Nordic languages, and can offer services into Swedish, Danish, Finnish, Norwegian and Icelandic. The premier translation agency for Norway and the Nordic region! Technical translation services for businesses in the Nordic countries and translation agencies world-wide.
by: carmen
Responding Bad Markert With Mobile Crusher Two Tips About How To Choose Genuine Camphorwood Furniture Dress According To The Occasion! The Top 3 Things To Look For When Choosing A Hearing Aid Specialist The Essential Process In Iron Ore Extraction Is White Paint Furniture Still Popular? Wear Branded Shoes-why? Five Tips About How To Maintain Camphor Wood In Daily Life Benefits Of Private Guitar Lessons Exactly What Awful Inundation Control Programs Might Cause You A Filipino Breakthrough Plagiarized Choose The Best Corfu Resort For Your Luxurious Vacation Bygningstyper Med Brugen Af Byggeri